A father shared his heart-wrenching experience of bidding farewell to his wife and newborn daughter who passed away within hours of each other following a home birth.
Rob Cahill courageously recounted the tragic events at an inquest where his wife, Jen, aged 34, passed away the day after giving birth to their second child, Agnes. Despite efforts, Agnes also succumbed four days later on June 3 at their family residence in Bury, Greater Manchester.
The NHS hospital trust staff criticized the decision for a home birth as being “out of guidance” and “against advice” due to concerns stemming from Jennifer’s previous childbirth experience. However, Rob stated that the family was unaware of these concerns beforehand.
Rob described the heartbreaking moment when he had to call emergency services as Agnes showed signs of distress. Despite efforts to resuscitate her, she could not be saved. Further investigations are ongoing to determine the causes of death for both Jennifer and Agnes.
Reflecting on the ordeal, Rob expressed gratitude for the time spent with Agnes, highlighting her as a source of comfort amidst the tragedy.
The community midwife, Caroline Nixon, revealed in court that Jennifer, classified as high-risk, should have been referred to a senior midwife due to her condition, potentially leading her to reconsider a home birth.
Jennifer’s previous childbirth complications, including postpartum haemorrhage and risks of infection transmission, prompted a recommendation for a hospital birth with active management for her second delivery. Despite initial concerns, Jennifer opted for a home birth for a more personalized birthing experience.
Midwife Ms. Nixon adhered to trust policies by referring Jennifer to a doctor due to her high-risk status, although this deviated from the original plan. Despite discussions and reviews of risks, Jennifer remained steadfast in her decision for a home birth.
While acknowledging that Jennifer understood the risks involved, Ms. Nixon admitted she should have taken further steps when Jennifer declined certain tests, as this decision was also considered ‘out of guidance.’
Rob emphasized that the hospital’s preference for a hospital birth was primarily due to Jennifer being a strep B carrier, with less emphasis on postpartum haemorrhage, as noted in Jennifer’s medical records throughout her pregnancy.
