Kalshi and Polymarket Celebrate Big Wins in Midterm Election Betting

Date:

Kalshi and Polymarket quickly took to social media to boast about their successes on midterm election night, highlighting what they claim was precise forecasting.

Given the billions wagered on these prediction platforms, which permitted traders to bet on the outcomes of candidates and the balance of power in the Senate and House, their precision garnered significant attention. Media outlets like CNN and MSNBC shared odds from prediction markets during their midterm coverage, while celebrities such as YG and actress Heidi Montag discussed their midterm bets on election night.

Kalshi’s recap of the midterm elections reported that $2.5 billion US was exchanged on its markets, nearly doubling the $1.3 billion US recorded during the 2024 election cycle. Polymarket noted nearly $700 million US in bets during this election cycle across its US and international platforms, according to Reuters.

Polymarket stated on X that the prediction-market platform was “correct,” asserting that “98.4 percent of resolved midterm races were won by the Polymarket favorite the day before Election Day.”

Similarly, Kalshi claimed that candidates favored on its platform won or were leading in 98 percent of races before polls closed on election day.

Valerie Cross, head of emerging verticals at NEXTPredict.io, which tracked Kalshi and Polymarket on election night, mentioned that while those statistics might not be inaccurate, “it’s easy to overinterpret.”

She further explained that these figures demonstrate how prediction markets effectively incorporated “early returns, exit polls, and county counts rapidly, and largely moved in the correct direction.”

“They also quickly indicated potential upsets, as raw vote tallies can make a race appear closer than the odds suggest,” she added.

WATCH | Record betting on U.S. midterms raises questions about whether prediction markets influence voters:

What happens when election betting goes mainstream

November 2|

Duration

6:11

Kalshi and Polymarket election prediction markets are seeing record trades ahead of the 2026 U.S. midterms. For The National, CBC’s Ashley Fraser explores how betting odds can influence American voters and if the platforms risk distorting public perception.

Predicting a blue tsunami

Although the platforms were largely accurate in predicting winners, they failed to foresee some of the more unexpected races of the evening.

An analysis conducted by Betting Intelligence on over 400 races uncovered 14 upsets, all won by Democratic candidates.

One notable upset occurred in the South Carolina Senate race, where prediction markets favored Republican candidate Darline Graham, estimating her chances of winning at approximately 70 percent before Democrat Annie Andrews claimed an unexpected victory.

Other surprising outcomes included Democrat Gina Hinojosa defeating incumbent Republican Governor Greg Abbott in Texas, with markets assigning Hinojosa a 40.1 percent chance of winning the day before the election.

The firm concluded that both polls and prediction markets “identified the eventual winner with equal frequency, and both underestimated Democratic candidates.”

David Szakyoni, co-founder of the Anti-Corruption Data Collective, which analyzes prediction markets utilizing publicly available information, stated that the markets “seem to react to vote counts and polling data, rather than offering something unique.”

Rajiv Sethi, an economist at Columbia University, noted that neither polls nor prediction markets were able to “foresee the magnitude” of Democratic victories on election night.

He highlighted races where both polls and markets were inaccurate to better understand their impact, such as the closely contested Mississippi Senate race.

A graphic reading: "Prediction-market election"

(CBC)

The Associated Press has yet to call the race, with Democrat Scott Colom currently leading Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith by 1,803 votes as of Thursday afternoon.

Neither predictions nor markets anticipated the razor-thin margin between the candidates, but Sethi noted that prediction markets provided Colom with a slightly higher chance than polls indicated, citing their ability to respond to candidate errors or successes during the campaign.

“[Polls] can’t capture the truly unique developments that markets can. That is the strength of the market.”

However, despite their quicker reactions, markets still depend on polling data for their forecasts.

“The markets react to the models. Without those models, the markets would assess things quite differently.”

Before the networks

Cross concurred that markets cannot always be directly compared to polls.

“They measure different factors at different times, and they rely on each other more than headlines suggest.”

She emphasized that “For an early assessment of who is likely to prevail on Election Day, nothing surpasses prediction markets.”

“Traders are factoring in all available information into their predictions,” Cross explained. “At 8:12 p.m., with roughly 31 percent of votes counted in South Carolina, Andrews led 52 percent to 46 percent, while NBC stated it was too soon to declare a winner.”

Polymarket CEO Shayne Copland expressed on X, “There is now a significant delay between when prediction markets make their calls and when TV networks do.”

WATCH | Prediction markets are booming, but experts warn of gambling, insider trading and manipulation:

Prediction markets let you bet on anything — but is it just gambling?

April 5|

Duration

7:48

Prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket have exploded in popularity, processing billions in daily trades. For The National, CBC’s Nora Young breaks down how they work and why experts say it’s just another form of gambling that comes with risks of insider trading and manipulation.

Kalshi CEO Terek Mansour echoed a similar sentiment, stating, “For generations, election night has meant tuning into the TV and waiting for a select few individuals to tell you what transpired. Prediction markets are transforming that.”

According to Betting Intelligence, during the majority of closely contested races, prediction markets achieved a 97 percent probability for the eventual winner approximately one hour before The Associated Press declared the race. No candidates that reached that threshold ultimately lost.

Despite these early predictions, Szakonyki expressed skepticism that prediction markets significantly contributed to the electoral dialogue during this cycle.

Conversely, Cross noted that the trading volume clearly indicates a strong level of interest.

“Midterms typically garner only a fraction of the attention that presidential races do. If these midterms can generate such figures, the 2028 elections could be magnitudes larger.”

Popular

More like this
Related

Cody Lightning’s ‘Smudge the Blades’ Tackles Indigenous Youth in Sports

Cody Lightning, a Cree actor and filmmaker, was the...

Democrats Flip Key Seats, Gain Control of Congress in Midterm Upset

On Tuesday night, the Democrats gained control by achieving...

Alberta Officer Escapes Charges for AI-Generated Explicit Images

An officer from Alberta Sheriffs will not face criminal...

Deer Harvest Set to Begin in Dundas Valley for Haudenosaunee Tradition

According to the Hamilton Conservation Authority (HCA), the Haudenosaunee...