Edmonton Woman Sentenced to House Arrest After Dog Attack Death

Date:

A woman from Edmonton, who was the owner of two large dogs responsible for the death of an 11-year-old boy in 2024, has been sentenced to a conditional house arrest of two years minus a day, as determined by a judge on Thursday.

Crystal Jean MacDonald, 46, was convicted of criminal negligence causing death in May after a trial presided over solely by a judge at the Edmonton Court of King’s Bench. The incident that led to Kache Grist’s death occurred on April 1, 2024, when MacDonald’s two Cane Corsos attacked him.

On Thursday, Justice Eric Macklin handed down the sentence to MacDonald, which includes a lifetime prohibition from owning, supervising, or controlling dogs, with the possibility of applying for a leave on this condition in 10 years.

Additionally, she is required to complete 200 hours of community service.

Justice Macklin cited several aggravating factors in the case, such as MacDonald’s failure to adequately train her dogs, their prior attacks on humans, their involvement in the deaths of two other pets, Kache’s young age and vulnerability, and the brutal nature of the incident. However, he acknowledged that MacDonald had expressed concern for Kache, that there was no intent to harm him, and that she exhibited “great remorse.”

“Though the seriousness of the offence is considerable, it does not automatically place her moral culpability at the highest level,” Macklin stated. “Ms. MacDonald recognized that her dogs were capable of causing harm to Kache, yet she did not anticipate they would do so.

“She did not intentionally aim to injure Kache, nor did she ever wish for him to be harmed or killed.”

MacDonald will be serving her sentence in Penticton, B.C.

While the Crown sought a five-year prison term, the defence argued for a conditional sentence of two years less a day.

After the proceedings, defence attorney Evan McIntyre informed reporters that MacDonald has filed for an appeal regarding her conviction.

“[Even with the appeal], it doesn’t contradict the fact that she feels immense remorse,” he stated. “However, it is also her legal right to have this matter reviewed by a higher court.

“This entire ordeal has been profoundly emotional for her.

“The Indigenous impact report highlights the effects this has had on her. I suspect that nobody feels content about being sentenced, but she seems to take some comfort in the sentence.”

The court received details from an Indigenous background report indicating that MacDonald identifies as Métis and is associated with the Mi’kmaq band.

The report revealed that MacDonald has memories of witnessing violence between her parents and noted that she “experienced numerous adverse childhood experiences,” including poverty, physical and sexual abuse, neglect, and involvement with child welfare.

During the sentencing on Wednesday, an emotional victim impact statement was presented virtually by Kache’s father, Wesley Grist, who described Kache as the most significant person in his life and an integral part of his identity.

“The grief is unending,” he shared with the courtroom, further stating that he views the incident as a tragic situation.

He expressed that he never sought revenge for his son’s passing and that MacDonald will have to bear the burden of his death.

“At no time was my testimony delivered with malice,” Wesley remarked. “I never wished for harm to come to her [MacDonald]. I know she cared for Kache.

“This doesn’t feel like a win for me.”

MacDonald was also granted the chance to speak in court. Through tears, she conveyed the guilt, sorrow, and shame she experiences.

“I love Kache profoundly,” she said. “I think about him every single day.

“I can’t articulate what it feels like to be here due to the death of a child I cherish.”

Kache’s mother, Kendrah Wong, attended the courtroom on Wednesday. Wong submitted a victim impact statement but requested it to be read privately.

Trial testimonies

MacDonald was the owner of two Cane Corso dogs, Khaos and Khairo, both of which have since been euthanized. The court heard that Khaos weighed approximately 56 kilograms (124 pounds) and Khairo weighed over 49 kilograms (109 pounds) at the time of the incident.

During the trial, it was revealed that Kache was visiting his father, Wesley, in Edmonton from Osoyoos, B.C., for spring break and was staying at MacDonald’s residence in south Edmonton.

Wesley testified that on April 1, 2024, Kache briefly stepped out of the home to purchase snacks at a nearby Circle K.

At that time, MacDonald was not present.

Wesley mentioned that he was working in the garage while the dogs remained inside. Upon Kache’s return from the convenience store, he went inside to play video games, and later, Wesley discovered his son lying on the kitchen floor.

Wesley testified that MacDonald had previously cautioned him to keep Kache away from the dogs and not to leave him alone with them.

An autopsy revealed that Kache died from a dog-bite injury to the neck, with additional injuries noted on his upper back, shoulders, and arms.

Throughout the trial, evidence was presented regarding earlier attacks involving the dogs, including incidents with MacDonald herself, an acquaintance, and a former tenant. The dogs had previously fatally attacked two pets as well.

MacDonald testified that she was aware of her dogs exhibiting aggressive behavior prior to Kache’s death but believed she had taken measures to manage them, including utilizing kennels and seeking professional training.

She argued that some of the earlier incidents could have been avoided if individuals had adhered to the rules she established for the dogs.

When Macklin announced his decision in May, he concluded that the primary factor leading to Kache’s death was MacDonald’s failure to take reasonable precautions to ensure he was safe from the two untrained and unpredictable dogs.

Popular

More like this
Related

RCMP Confirms Ongoing Cooperation Amid FBI Director’s Threats

The Commissioner of the RCMP stated that there is...

Maple Leaf Foods to Raise Prices Again Amid Rising Costs and Inflation

Consumers can expect more troubling news at the grocery...

Russell Brand Found Guilty of Rape and Sexual Assault Charges

British actor and comedian Russell Brand was found guilty...

Scarborough MP’s Car Set Ablaze in Suspected Arson Attack

Authorities are looking into a suspected arson case at...