The families affected by the Manchester Arena bombing have expressed their dissatisfaction with the current version of a proposed Hillsborough law aimed at preventing cover-ups. Concerned campaigners recently met with Sir Keir Starmer to discuss their worries about potential exemptions for intelligence agencies in the law’s transparency obligations. Despite the meeting, they were disappointed with the outcome.
Ruth Leney, leading the Manchester Arena Support Network, acknowledged Sir Keir’s receptiveness but stressed the need for full accountability without any dilution, particularly concerning security services. Campaigners cautioned that the draft Hillsborough Law, also known as the Public Office (Accountability) Bill, could allow intelligence leaders to shield serious lapses under the guise of national security.
Referencing the 2017 Arena bombing, where MI5 was criticized for withholding crucial information, campaigners emphasized the importance of ensuring transparency across all sectors, including intelligence services. In response, Sir Keir affirmed that the duty of candor applies to intelligence agencies and defended proposed amendments to maintain a balance between accountability and national security.
Proposed amendments brought intelligence agencies under the law’s purview, subject to approval from their respective heads. However, concerns were raised about the potential unchecked discretion of security service heads in disclosing information, leading to calls for greater oversight.
Some families of victims, like Caroline Curry and Lisa Rutherford, expressed dismay over the amendments, feeling misled and anxious about the implications. They emphasized the importance of honesty and accountability in seeking justice for their loved ones lost in the tragic incident.
MPs postponed the debate on the Hillsborough Law to address campaigners’ apprehensions, with the Government pledging to work closely with families to enhance the bill while upholding national security interests. Notably, the law’s namesake stems from the 1989 Hillsborough disaster, where misinformation and cover-ups marred the investigation into the tragic event.
Despite assurances from the Government about enhanced scrutiny on security services, concerns persist among campaigners and lawmakers. Liverpool Labour MP Ian Byrne intends to propose amendments ensuring full accountability for security services unless the Government revises its stance.
The ongoing dialogue reflects the families’ unwavering pursuit of justice and transparency in the aftermath of the Manchester Arena tragedy.
