As Good Friday approaches, many are on the hunt for the perfect homemade “chippy tea.” To help you avoid disappointment with a soggy batter, we conducted a test of popular supermarket battered cod options to find out which one truly captures the essence of a coastal fish and chips experience without the high price tag.
Among the selections from Asda, Aldi, Tesco, and Sainsbury’s, one standout emerged as the top choice for those seeking to recreate the takeaway delight. From budget-friendly alternatives to fillets that closely resemble the authentic seaside offering, we present the definitive ranking for your Easter fish feast. Accompanied by chunky chips, peas, a twist of lemon, and curry sauce, here’s how they stacked up:
Starting with Sainsbury’s Battered MSC Cod Fillets (£4.50 for two), the packaging was appealing, and the fillets cooked quickly, turning out moist and flaky. The batter crisped up nicely, providing a chip shop-like crunch, while the fish itself had a fresh taste and a satisfying texture. Overall, a highly satisfying option deserving of a repeat purchase.
Rating: 4/5
Next up, Tesco’s Battered Cod Fillets (£3.95 for two) impressed with generous fillet sizes packed with flavorful white fish. The fillets boasted a strong fish taste akin to authentic chippy offerings, complemented by a light, crispy batter that cooked well. This option delivered a genuine fish and chip shop experience without excessive greasiness, making it a top contender in our taste test.
Rating: 5/5
Asda’s Battered Cod Fillets (£4.37 for four) proved to be a wallet-friendly choice, boasting a golden appearance post-cooking. While the fish was flaky and of expected consistency, it fell slightly short on flavor compared to Tesco’s offering. Despite this, given the affordable price point, these fillets are a solid value for those seeking a budget-friendly fish dinner option.
Rating: 3/5
Aldi’s Battered Cod (£3.39 for four) emerged as the most economical option, albeit with some trade-offs in quality. While the batter appeared golden after cooking, it veered slightly towards the soggy side. The fish was fresh and tasty, but the fillets were smaller in size and lacked the fullness expected. Nevertheless, considering the price point, Aldi’s offering provides decent value for a quick fish supper.
Rating: 2/5
