Ontario may have issued its inaugural fine against a ticket resale platform under the province’s anti-scalping legislation, which is being scrutinized as resellers attempt to sell tickets for forthcoming events like the Toronto International Film Festival.
According to the province’s consumer protection website, SeatGeek Canada received a fine of $25,000 in late August, with no other penalties recorded for ticket sellers, indicating that SeatGeek could be the first to incur financial penalties under the ticket resale law that was implemented in April.
Details of the fine reveal that the company was charged $10,000 for allegedly selling a ticket at a price exceeding its face value, $5,000 for failing to disclose the original purchase price, and another $10,000 for allegedly facilitating a sale without evidence of the original price.
Cristian Buzo Tingarov, a representative for Ontario’s Minister of Public and Business Service Delivery, Stephen Crawford, did not respond to inquiries on Thursday regarding the specific event linked to the fines or whether additional fines would be imposed.
-
Ticketmaster removes Ontario resale tickets following new law price caps
-
Can eliminating scalpers improve the ticketing industry?
“Every ticket seller in Ontario is required to adhere to our laws that ban the resale of tickets above their face value,” he mentioned in an email. “Any seller who violates these regulations may face fines of up to $250,000 and be publicly listed.”
SeatGeek’s stance on fines remains uncertain
Joe Freeman, SeatGeek’s vice-president of government affairs, did not clarify whether the company intends to pay the fines or contest them.
Although SeatGeek has informed third-party sellers on its platform regarding the law, he mentioned that the company is still seeking guidance from the province on how to adhere to the regulations.
Freeman indicated that it is often difficult for SeatGeek to verify a ticket’s original value because “many sellers, including those with season tickets, do not have access to the original face value of their tickets.”
“This results in independent platforms, such as SeatGeek, having limited capacity to acquire or confirm the price paid at the time of purchase from the primary seller.”
StubHub Canada expressed a similar viewpoint when addressing inquiries about the Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) screenings recently featured on its site.

Certain listings for the Toronto International Film Festival, such as Fjord, appeared to exceed the prices reported by fans during member sales on the resale site Vivid Seats. (Laura Proctor/The Canadian Press)
One pair of tickets for Werner Herzog’s love triangle drama Bucking Fastar was listed on StubHub for over $2,300, while a single seat for the debut of the Hudson Williams-led television show Yaga was offered for $777.
TIFF did provide feedback regarding ticket pricing.
StubHub claims uncertainty over original prices
Fans who secured seats during member sales last week noted that premium screenings, which often feature a Q-and-A session with the cast or director, were listed for over $128.
Earlier this summer, TIFF offered a curated ticket package for five highly anticipated premieres at a cost of $1,760, averaging out to about $352 per ticket.
StubHub suggested that listings appearing above face value result from the platform’s inability to verify what buyers originally paid for tickets.
The company contends that some tickets, particularly those bought in a season package, lack price labels, and receipts can easily be manipulated by resellers aiming to sell tickets at inflated prices.
StubHub asserts that it requires data from the original platform where a ticket was purchased to verify prices and adhere to the law.
“Several key issues, such as what evidence sellers should present to validate a ticket’s original price, remain unresolved,” the company stated in an email. “We are dedicated to collaborating with the government to tackle these concerns.”
Certain TIFF listings that seem to exceed the prices reported by fans during member sales also appeared on Vivid Seats.
Ticket for film premiere listed at $933 on one platform
A ticket for the premiere of the Palme d’Or-winning film Fjord was available on the platform for $933, while a ticket to the debut of the soccer star biopic Rapinoe was priced at $483 this week.
Julia Young, a spokesperson for Vivid Seats, stated that it is “factually incorrect” to imply the company is violating legislation, as it has been engaged in “active discussions with the Ontario government and has made adjustments to ensure compliance with the requirements set forth by the province’s new ticket resale regulations.”
“Undertaking changes of this magnitude necessitates clear, consistent guidance throughout the industry, and we continue to collaborate with Ontario officials to clarify the law and facilitate its effective implementation,” she wrote in an email.
-
‘Not a people’s festival any longer’: TIFF fans confront rising ticket prices
-
Former Toronto mayor John Tory appointed as new chair of TIFF’s board
In late April and early May, the province sent letters to 27 ticket resale websites, including StubHub and Vivid Seats, informing them that inspections for non-compliance with the new law would occur.
The correspondence from the province cautioned that this process could lead to follow-up inspections and noted that if a business “fails to cooperate, enforcement measures may follow.”
Following the issuance of these letters, StubHub was added to the province’s consumer beware list for alleged non-compliance. The entry has not been updated with any information regarding fines.
Vivid Seats spokesperson Young stated to The Canadian Press in July that the company had addressed nearly all areas of non-compliance highlighted by the Ontario government.
She mentioned that Vivid Seats anticipated full compliance that month but was still in discussions with the province regarding how to fulfill its obligations.

